Contact
Join
Login

The importance of data quality

Checking the accuracy of vital events records

Methods and tools to evaluate the quality of vital statistics

Tabulation and generation of vital statistics for national policy

Presentation, communication and dissemination of vital statistics

Learn how to use the Learning Centre

Move your way through the CRVS system or simply click on a topic to dive into a specific subject.

An account lets you:

  • Save resources from our Library
  • Track your progress through the Learning Centre
  • Sign-up for our free newsletter

Methods and tools to evaluate the quality of vital statistics

Approaches to measure the quality of reporting of birth characteristics

The quality of reporting of characteristics of the birth or persons directly involved in the birth is paramount to ensure good-quality fertility statistics. The UN’s Principles and recommendations for a vital statistics system, revision 3 recommends a set of characteristics that should be collected from the birth event. Some of which are discussed below.

The United Nations recommends that the following characteristics are collected in connection with the birth record for birth statistics purposes:

  • Sex of child
  • Weight of child
  • Gestational age of child
  • Birth order
  • Age of mother
  • Date and place of the occurrence of the event – that is, the place of delivery
  • Place of usual residence
  • Attendant at birth
  • Date and place of the registration of the event
  • Type of birth – for example, single, twin or triplet
  • Time since last birth.

The United Nations also recommends collecting a comprehensive list of characteristics of the child’s parents which are used for different tabulations of natality and fertility statistics:

Sex of child

The percentage of births with unspecified sex should be very low and is a sign of poor quality data. 

The sex ratio at birth (SRB; the number of male births per 100 female births) should be in the range of 103–107. A SRB in excess of 107 generally signifies son preference in fertility behaviour and abortion of female fetuses, unless it is a result of poor-quality data. 

Birth order

Birth order is an important fertility characteristic that is used to help understand fertility behaviour. It should measure all previous live births of the mother, not just births in the current marriage or relationship. Average birth order should be higher if the mother is older. A different pattern would suggest poor-quality data. The percentage of births with unspecified birth order should be low.

Birth weight
 
Birth weight is an important health indicator of newborns. The plausibility of birth weight data would be assessed by the proportion of children with low birth weight (less than 2500 grams) by age of mother. Generally, low birth weight is more common among younger mothers (younger than 20 years). 
 
The percentage of births with unspecified birth weight should be low, but is commonly quite high, particularly if many births take place outside health facilities.
 
Other characteristics
 
Other important indicators of the characteristics of births should also have low percentage of unspecified cases, which include:
 
  • Place of delivery
  • Attendant at birth
  • Gestational age
  • Time since last birth
  • Place of usual residence.

A large percentage of data missing for these characteristics could signal poor data quality and should be further evaluated.

Source:

1 United Nations (2014). Principles and recommendations for a vital statistics system, revision 3, UN, New York.

© University of Melbourne 2018   For more information on copyright visit our website terms